[AI] Asmarino Independent

  • Create an account
    *
    *
    *
    *
    *
    Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.
You are here: Home Editorial Ministry of Information: Egypt Failed Because, Unlike Eritrea, It Violated Basic Human Rights

Ministry of Information: Egypt Failed Because, Unlike Eritrea, It Violated Basic Human Rights

Write e-mail Print

Sorry guys for having failed you to report on parts III, IV, V, VI, VII and VIII of the series Popular Uprising: Eve of the End of Era of Domination and Transition to New World Order that Shabait.com has been churning out at a rapid rate. But if we are to summarize this whole series in one sentence, it would say: Egypt has failed because it didn’t pursue the self-reliant way that Gamal Abdel Nasser pioneered (and, incidentally, one that Eritrea subscribes to).

To prove the success of Nasser’s Egypt and its “self reliance policy”, as opposed to the failure of his successors’ “open door policy”, here is the bombshell – nay, the nuke – that the PFDJ dropped (call it the Mother of All Lies):

“During the leadership of Gamal Abdel Nasir, Egypt managed to meet 85% of its food needs thanks to the agricultural and industrial revolution.  Besides, it succeeded in setting up over 1,200 various industrial plants, in addition to establishing big military industries in a bid to strengthen its defense capacity. The capital of the production enterprises amounted to USD 1,400 billion during that period, according to the World Bank. Egypt’s GDP also exceeded that of the G-7 countries of today by 4 to 5%.

This mountain of LIE has probably no parallel in the history of economics. Even the US economy started counting its GDP in trillion only during the 70s. But then again they needed that kind of statistics to assert an even bigger lie they followed it up with: that “Egypt’s GDP also exceeded that of the G-7 countries of today by 4 to 5%.” The Ministry of Truth is telling us that Egypt’s GDP during Nasser era exceeded the GDP of the likes of Canada, France, Italy, UK, Germany, Japan and US today!

What, indeed, has gone wrong with the Ministry of Information writers? Why have they gone haywire in their analysis? Are they being told to write these lies with a gun pointed at their heads? Or are they deliberately sabotaging the regime? The usual maxim for a believable lie is: lie as close to the truth as possible. These idiots though seem to go to the opposite end of this advice: their lies are so farfetched that it wouldn’t even fool their dimwit foot soldiers in Dehai.

All these lies though are meant to prove one thing and only one thing only: when it comes to economics (and everything else – military, politics, diplomacy, etc), there is no match to the self reliant way that Eritrea strictly adheres to. So why did Egypt fail: because it replaced Nasser’s “self-reliance policy” with Sadat’s and Mubarak’s “open door policy”. And, of course, behind every assertion is a huge lie. We cannot go over all their self-serving lies, but provide you only with a sample:

On government vs the people

The “open-door policy” is, of course, the doing of none other than the evil US and its collaborator IMF:

“The first demand put forth for Sadat after falling under the yoke of US hegemony was change of previous policies. And as such, he was compelled to change his economic and political policies. The so-called ‘open economy policy’ that Sadat pursued in order to reconcile with the western countries was in gross disregard to the country’s 20-year old policy. The ‘open economy’ in essence amounted to limiting government’s role in directing development programs and totally placing the national economy under the private sector through refraining the government from getting involved in the work of all economic institutions. …”

The lesson # 1 that we are supposed to get out of this is: Interpreted in PFDJ lingo, and not so subtly conveyed to Eritreans, the above quote goes as follows: “Eritrea is doing fine because it has destroyed all the private sector and replaced it with government owned companies.” And all this wisdom is attributed to its newly discovered guru – none other than Gamal Abdel Nasser!

But this “open-door policy” is an overarching one that includes political, military and diplomatic sectors, besides the obvious economic sector. And the Shabait wiz kids have to find a lesson in each of those fields pertinent to the Eritrean condition.

On respecting basic human rights

When it comes to “political openness”, here is how the MOI admonishes all those who violate basic human rights:

“It thus became obvious that Sadat’s resort to ‘political openness’ was not to his advantage taking into account the growing internal and external opposition.  Although he allowed nominal political pluralism and freedom of expression, he was not at all willing to tolerate any opposition as regards the Camp David accord. Hence, it is not surprising to witness that he not only applied force but also prevented the exercise of basic human rights in a bid to suppress the mounting opposition.

Lesson # 2: If Sadat had used peaceful means and allowed “the exercise of basic human rights” (including political pluralism and freedom of expression) when dealing with the opposition, the way Isaias has done in Eritrea in all his Peaceful Magnificence (as every Human Rights group in the world would attest!) – all said and done in a “self reliant” way – Egypt wouldn’t have been in such a mess. So what Egypt lacked is the “political openness” practiced in Eritrea! Boy, oh boy, we don’t think even North Korea would attempt to get away with such a mountain of lie.

On the iron will of Isaias

And when it comes to the quality of leadership that Egypt lacked, look no more than our own Beloved, Benevolent and All Wise Isaias Afwerki as a role model:

“President Housni Mubarak who became Egyptian leader after the assassination of Anwar Sadat applied the policy of ‘openness’ on a bigger scale. ….. In other respects too, he was not that firm and courageous in decision-making. In light of this, external forces keen to undermine Egypt’s political, economic and military capacity welcomed Housni Mubarak’s assumption of the Office of Presidency.”

Lesson # 3: Had Mubarak been as “firm and courageous in decision-making” as our iron-willed Isaias, he wouldn’t have given in to outside forces (the forces of imperialism and colonialism), and would have achieved all that Eritrea has achieved politically, economically and militarily! No wonder at one time, the Highdef media was talking about “hatsinawi menfes” of His Excellency.

On the state of emergency

Most brilliantly, what the PFDJ abhors is the state of emergency:

“… The release of political prisoners detained in the days of Sadat rule was one of the steps he took. Nonetheless, Mubarak let the state of emergency declared by Sadat continue as before under the pretext of controlling the activities of extremist elements. It is to be noted that this declaration remained in force for 30 years until the recent stepping down of Housni Mubarak…”

Thanks God Eritrea has never declared any “state of emergency”! That is why in Eritrea there are no extremist elements! Had it declared a state of emergency, this would have meant, among other things, suspension of independent media, detention without due process of law, indefinite national service – all of which don’t exist in Eritrea! But since Mubarak did declare a state of emergency, look at the mess the put the nation through.

On the Iraqi invasion

And the Isaias regime, world-wide known for its principle and tsin’at, has nothing but contempt for Mubarak betraying Iraq:

“… The fact that it [Egypt] supported US invasion of Iraq both in 1990 and 2003, Israeli attack against Lebanon and the Gaza Strip, as well as its failure to strongly oppose Ethiopia’s invasion of Somalia made it an impotent nation lacking an independent decision-making.”

Hmmm! Wasn’t Eritrea the first nation in the region to jump into the bandwagon of the “Coalition of the Willing”? And wasn’t it Egypt’s bidding that the Isaias regime has been doing in Somalia? Even the most recent memories have to be erased to give way to highdef logic.

Well, guys, the Pinocchio list of the Ministry of Information Serving the Truth is very long. All that you have to do is visit Shabait and the follow the series on their Mideast analysis … if you haven’t had enough already.

Conclusion

Dear readers, we will leave you with what the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (not to be outdone by Ministry of Information’s brilliant analysis) has come out today regarding the UN’s resolution to suspend Libya’s membership:

“The Eritrean government believes that it would be legally and morally unjustified to pass a motion or a resolution on the 'suspension of the right of membership of the Libyan Arab Jamahiriya in the UN Human Rights Council' without/ before conducting appropriate full and independent investigation on the matter.”

Amazing! It dares to invoke legality and morality – two things that are found in Eritrea in their abundance! It seems that the MOI, after all, is not so keen on the Popular Uprising it has made subject of its analysis. Doesn’t it want the “Eve of the End of Era of Domination and Transition to New World Order” to come soon?

 

Comments  

 
+3 #20 weldezgi 2011-03-06 03:22
The dictatorial regime in Asmara will continue to lash at the west in general and curse the US and Ethiopia in particular. Every body knows why except for the blinds supporters. It is difficult to stick to power for long without election. It is also difficult to use force to silence your own people if you become a member of the world community. If you choose to join the other world - that of North-Corea, then the result is isolation...which both Eritrea and North corea are suffering. Isolation leads to economic deterioration and frustration. repression leads to internal instability and further frustration. frustration also leads to trivial accusation of all countries which the thuggish regime in Asmara is doing. When the cursing, blaming and accusing Ethiopia and the US becomes daily routine though it becomes a useless noise and irritating even to its own supporters.
 
 
+9 #19 Amani 2011-03-05 20:20
The Ministry of foreign Affairs is asking the world where is the evidence due to their Mu'ammar Ghadafi's crimes whilst his friend is announcing and threatning that he would change Libya to a red fire should the rebelss did not stope and his killing squads are killing people everywhere.
 
 
+2 #18 cataclysmic 2011-03-05 14:14
The U.S president , a leader of the free world said yesterday in a press conference that "....Khafafy has lost legitimacy to lead .....he must leave " . It would be a music to all Eritreans ears to hear such statements made about Eritrean leadership!!!
Mr. Obama may shun the title "Leader of the free World " , but he nonetheless owes the world some leadership . A lot of suffering people ( including Eritreans ) are desperate for it !!!
 
 
+5 #17 Absurd 2011-03-05 13:38
Oh my God ! Shabia is venturing to talk about basic human rights ? Is the prison in Ira-Iro located in China ? How can an institute like this serve the truth if it doesn't know the difference between truth and lie? A leader who was travelling to Egypt to seek Mubarek's friendship is now betraying him openly in the same way as he betrayed the Eritrean people and the friends who brought him to power.Do the Shabia.com intellectuals know how Egypt had to suffer under the 6 days' war ? A government which cannot administer 4m people is now talking about Egypt with more than 80m. Absurd !
 
 
-13 #16 Yonatan 2011-03-05 09:26
I am not supporting the government of Erirea about thier internal policy however, the overall analysis of the gov has right in some case the problem in the Arab world. The neo-liberal economic system is creating a lot of problems not only in the arab world but also around the world. The main actors are the IMF and the World bank, this two instutions are not democratic . I am pro democracy but the movement has to start from the grassroot organisations not from the US based NGos and the so called human right organisations. As we know from history the US government has never been pro democracy for exmple in 1954 the overthrow of the democratecally elected Jacobo Arbenz government in Guatemala, Chile the government of Salvador Allende in 1973 CIA sponsored coup`deta why these two goverments were against US interests. So we have to protest against dictators however, we have to be careful with US involvement as well.
 
 
0 #15 Observer 2011-03-05 03:35
All editorials and minstry of foreign affairs are written by none other than PIA himself. The statements start with irritating half a million questions like "why did the UN passed the Libyan resolution? What is the purpose? For what? By who? Who is behind it? Why not do so on other countries? Why at this precise time? Who is orchestrating these? Who is benefiting? how? when? where? in what way? for whom? by whom? to whom?.....
The annoying questions are endless......
 
 
+9 #14 zekre lebona 2011-03-05 03:24
It takes two to tango

In Orwell's 1984, Big Brother is always busy destroying any kind of books, documents, and the like in order hide its evil system. It fears the truth from the "literate" society. Our type of totalitarian regime, however, seems not to be bothered about hiding or deleting most things for the public is not only largely illiterate, but also swallows anything thrown at it. This equally applies to its elite. Their servility has no bottom.
 
 
+14 #13 HIMAM LIBI 2011-03-05 01:52
Ministry of foreign affairs knows it can not fool anybody except those of us that are brain dead, who believe that Isayas will feed us Chickens´ milk,,,,,The misinformation was meant for Eritrean consumption, I am not sure if it still works, as I have witnessed fellow Eritreans believe incredibly stupid stuff.
What the foreign ministry has issued is an insult to our intrlligence, to those of us who posses one !!!
ብሓቂ ተናዒቕና !!!!!!!!!!!
 
 
+10 #12 Yebio 2011-03-04 22:49
'Here we go again' to quote Regan. out of the blue Isayas the traitor, branded Sadat and Mubarek as traitors to Egypt's cause. How much uneducated and bully can the strongman of Asmara be to even pretend that he is democratic. Thank you Monkey and Ali Abdu for exposing the feeble minded leader of yours. Good journalistic rebuttal.
 
 
+8 #11 weldezgi 2011-03-04 20:31
abeba 2011-03-04 19:12

"Moreover, Higdefites do not remember what they had for breakfast 4 hours later"

Well said Abeba. that is why they continue to contradict with what they said earlier when ever they try to say some thing new. Yesterday they supported Iraqi's invasion and worked hard to offer Assab to the US. Today, they are saying they opposed it. Blind supporters do not have the ability to relate yesterday with today. They are blind! Are not they?
 
 
+12 #10 agony 2011-03-04 20:03
Well, look at the most recent speech by Muammer Kezzafy,
while the whole nation is in revolt against him, soon after he threatened Libyans he said something like this: “All people love Muammer Kezzafy”. And this is an absolute detachment from reality. Tyranny, can’t command truthful historical analysis, but convoluted hodgepodge editorials to feed the confused cohorts. In the house of Despotism there are no mirrors for reflection, vision and accountability but only distortions and outright lies. So, don’t waste your time to find something remotely close to veracity.
 
 
+9 #9 weldezgi 2011-03-04 19:21
"Egypt has failed because it didn’t pursue the self-reliance"

This is from a regime that has miserably failed to run Eritrean Airlines that could have been run successfully by one wealthy Eritrean.

What a shame!!!
 
 
+12 #8 abeba 2011-03-04 19:12
Higdef knows its supporters are ignorant. The majority of them can not write their names even in tigrigna. Thus they still have consumers- the ignorant blind supporters.

Moreover, Higdefites do not remember what they had for breakfast 4 hours later.
 
 
+17 #7 DB 2011-03-04 16:00
This really shows not only how dumb the GOE is but also how the GOE sees his supporters....DUMBER.
 
 
+7 #6 ruth g 2011-03-04 15:19
Peoples Front for Democracy and Justice as its name implies is a joke. To write about peoples power and justice is not their domain at all !!.Amharic misilla 'wusha min dollesh ke sew ersha'
 
 
+16 #5 themat ekud 2011-03-04 14:21
You got to love when the regime conveys such pack of lies and utterly foolish explanations. Nothing persuades the folks supporting regime that the regime is indeed a disgrace than these kinds of foolish remarks. I’m loving it that they didn’t keep their mouth shut. To Asmarino, good job ... you can be so funny!
 
 
+6 #4 cataclysmic 2011-03-04 14:06
I love it !!! Thank you Asmarino !
Am i drearming or is this the 21st century ?? I mean the so called analysis of the so called ministry of information is laughable to say the least . Eritrean government is the most ruthless tyrant ,who has effectevly created a climate of fear to it's people by bringing ruthless application of force to Eritrea . Eritrea is no longer part of the international economic development and Eritrea is never mentioned in a pleasent conversation in the world stage and that is due to our dear leader and we can thank him for that . Not to mention the human rights crises that is getting worse by the day . For the Eritrean leadership human rights abuse is a joike , and at best a denail . We all need to seize the moment and do what all brave people are doing around the world to rid off their dectators . WE Should Stand TOGETHER to free our suffering people . CLEAN YOUR SIDE OF STREET FIRST AND THEN SPEAK !!!!
 
 
+23 #3 thomass 2011-03-04 12:19
I do not have words to thank you Asmarino staff. I know you are doing the most of what u can. How wonderfull would it be if it were translated in to tigrigna and tigre...as more than 90% of our people can understand either or both of this languages. I know it is big ask,,,,but i have also a solution...Lets create volunteer traslation service. Then accross the world eritrean intelectuals (who are dormant so far) will get registered...then u will send us the articles...and we will send you back the translated once for editing before you post it.....Readers please rate this idea and show me what u think through your vote.
 
 
+22 #2 Angesom 2011-03-04 09:10
An excellent analysis Asmarino. May God bless you.

I liked the following statements, most.

So what Egypt lacked is the “political openness” practiced in Eritrea! Boy, oh boy, we don’t think even North Korea would attempt to get away with such a mountain of lie.
 
 
+16 #1 Yemane Johar 2011-03-04 06:23
"Well, guys, the Pinocchio list of the Ministry of Information Serving the Truth is very long. All that you have to do is visit Shabait and the follow the series on their Mideast analysis … if you haven’t had enough already." Well done brother!
 

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Asmarino

ኣዝማሪኖ (ትግሪኛ)

ICER Alert on Afar

ICER Alert on Afar

There is human catastrophe unfolding in Yemen  at this very minute. Two hundred and forty four Eritreans ninety five percent of whom are Afar citizens of Eritrea are in prison some for almost one year. Their crime is simply for entering Yemen without document. Their claim for political asylum until situation at home is improved was completely ignored by the Yemeni authorities and the UNHCR is on the sideline simply watching helpless.

As it is true with most Eritreans, this particular ethnic group is driven out of their traditional areas, prevented from leading their subsistence existence which is fishing on the Red Sea and forcibly conscripted in the open ended military National Service which has become scourge ....

Read more...

Desperate Situation of Eritrean Afar Refugees in Yemeni City of Al-Hudeyda

Desperate Situation of Eritrean Afar Refugees in Yemeni City of Al-Hudeyda

Regrettably, the 300 Afar refugees are languishing in Al-Hudeyda prison where their lives are trapped in a serious threat. Apart from consistent warnings of forcible return to Eritrea, they are facing communicable diseases caused by contaminated food and water. Amongst them are around 50 Afar refugees are in a grave danger of losing their lives to this disease outbreak.

Unfortunately, the ongoing political uncertainty in Yemen exasperated the situation of Red Sea Afar refugees. Going on almost a year in captivity, they haven’t had any access to UNHCR and Human rights organizations, representatives of Yemeni government or any access to medications and basic needs, which is guaranteed to them under UN Geneva convention on rights of refugees.

Read more...

Yosief Ghebrehiwet on Smerrr Paltalk on Saturday, May 12

Yosief Ghebrehiwet on Smerrr Paltalk on Saturday, May 12

On Saturday, May 12, at 12:00 PM (Los Angeles Time) or 21:00 (Berlin Time) Yosief Ghebrehiwet will give a presentation at Smerr Paltalk. The topic is "The Fallacies of the Democracy Project and Nationhood in the Eritrean Context" In this presentation, the following points will be discussed:

  1. What is wrong with the Democracy Project as practiced by the Opposition? On this part, more than a dozen fallacies will be discussed.
  2. After discussing the notion of "nationhood" in the Eritrean context, this question will be addressed: What is being done to hold Eritrea together as a nation?
  3. After looking at the rationale of the past (the Eritrean revolution) and the present (the opposition) movements regarding (1) and (2), we will look at this question: Given the above fallacies and failings, how do we anchor the Eritrean nation in the future?

 

Read more...

ICER APPEAL: Save Eritrean Refugees from Human Smugglers

ICER APPEAL: Save Eritrean Refugees from Human Smugglers

The International Commission on Eritrean Refugees (ICER) would like to appeal to all the political groups in particular to those whose operational base is Ethiopia to give focus on the issues affecting refugees in particular to the shady operation going on in the refugee camps. Frankly, since their base of operation is located stone throw away from Eritrea where the bulk of the refugees originate from we believe they are better placed than most of us to influence events, at least in as far as regulating the flow of persons from the refugee camps in Ethiopia and the Sudan. ...

This being the case, therefore, why is it so difficult for the political parties and in particular those operating from Ethiopia where part of the illegal activities is occurring cannot act in earnest to stop it?  Is it because  they are too preoccupied dealing with the more burning issues, for example, the overthrow of the unrepresentative regime and replacing it with democratic one? ...

Read more...

Support AI

AI Editorial

Famine in Self-Reliant Eritrea?

Famine in Self-Reliant Eritrea?

But don’t tell that to the regime’s foot soldiers in diaspora. As usual, the foot soldiers at Deahai and other Shaebia-oriented websites are at their denial and gloating best. They are again invoking that idiotic mantra that every totalitarian system (Kim El Sung’s North Korea, Mao’s China, Khmer Rouge’s Cambodia, etc ) used to hide a raging famine in their soils: “Self- reliance!” ...

Here we have it then in a nutshell: while all the other governments are scrambling to save their people, as usual the primary goal of the Eritrean regime and its supporters in diaspora is not saving Eritreans from the ravages of the famine, but saving the IMAGE of Eritrea and its leader from the ravages of that same famine!

Read more...

The Language of Shabait.com: The Incompetence of the Ministry of Information

The Language of Shabait.com: The Incompetence of the Ministry of Information

In the normal world, when reporters use the phrase “senior government official” without a name attached to it, it is because he/she is not supposed to provide the public with that information and the reporters feel obligated to hide his/her identity. But for the clowns at the Ministry of Information, it looked normal to identify their source as “a senior government official”, even though such anonymity is entirely unnecessary in this context. They are suggesting that Eritrea is a normal nation with a normal government, where unauthorized information leaked by government officials could be published without any retribution whatsoever to whoever is reporting it. They totally forgot that it is the government itself that is doing the reporting! What a tragedy for a nation to be lead by such Neanderthals!

Read more...

Isaias Regime’s Hysteria Concerning Stiffening Sanctions

Isaias Regime’s Hysteria Concerning Stiffening Sanctions

In his latest interview in Al-Ahram, President Isaias Afwerki claims that the sanctions are military and not economic. He clearly knows that it would be his end if the sanctions are extended to include economic sanctions. What the above Shabait.com hysteria shows us is the fear of the regime in this regard; its mention of the Eritrean Airlines and the Bisha project in particular tells us that economic sanctions would be its worst nightmare. And that is exactly what the opposition should focus at: at sanctioning Eritrea at its two main income sources – the mining companies and the diaspora population.

Read more...

Ministry of Information: Egypt Failed Because, Unlike Eritrea, It Violated Basic Human Rights

Ministry of Information: Egypt Failed Because, Unlike Eritrea, It Violated Basic Human Rights

When it comes to “political openness”, here is how Eritrea's MOI admonishes all those who violate basic human rights:

“It thus became obvious that Sadat’s resort to ‘political openness’ was not to his advantage taking into account the growing internal and external opposition.  Although he allowed nominal political pluralism and freedom of expression, he was not at all willing to tolerate any opposition as regards the Camp David accord. Hence, it is not surprising to witness that he not only applied force but also prevented the exercise of basic human rights in a bid to suppress the mounting opposition.

Read more...

The Minstry of Truth: Egypt Failed Because It Lacked Ethnic Harmony and Self-Reliant Economy Eritrea Has

The Minstry of Truth: Egypt Failed Because It Lacked Ethnic Harmony and Self-Reliant Economy Eritrea Has

Now we have come to the icing in the cake: nations like Libya, Tunisia and Egypt are falling like a house of cards because, unlike the glorious Eritrean economy that is the envy not only of our jealous neighbors but also of the entire world, their economies were never self-reliant! There you have it: the truth, nothing but whole the truth! Here is how the notoriously truthful Shabait.com puts it:

“Under this global scenario, it demands the requisite political will and strong courage to pursue political and economic path free from dependency. … In this regard, resorting to the principle of self-reliance is imperative. Viewed within this framework, the nations that resolutely pursued an independent path are the ones that emerged victorious, while those which compromised their independent choice are being exposed to all-round failure.”

Read more...
More:


Buying Time Eyewitness Account Blood Money News Analysis Editorial Writers' Corner News Articles Press Releases Latest